Take Off, Eh?

The English language has an unusual construction shared by few others. Even those related languages such as Dutch and German, which have a similar construction, make far less use of it. We call the structure a “phrasal verb”.

Phrasal verbs are, as you might imagine, phrases, or groups of words, which behave like a single verb. Most are combinations of two words, some are three, and rare examples of four or more can be found. What you have is a handful of words describing a single action or state of being.

“Break down”, “carry on”, and “put up with” are typical phrasal verbs. They depend in part on the core verb, or action word, but are qualified by the remainder, which is usually a preposition. The preposition will entirely alter the meaning– consider “keep in”, “keep down”, “keep up”, and “keep away”. And don’t count on things being as they seem: “keep it up” is not exactly the opposite of “keep it down”, and “give it up” isn’t even related conceptually to “give it away”.

Similarly, context can make all the difference when using the exact same phrasal verb: “take off” means one thing if you’re referring to an airplane, something else if you’re speaking of a coat, and yet something else if you’re referring to plagiarism.

These things drive learners of English absolutely nuts, because there is no discernable pattern or rule that you can teach. It’s like the gender of nouns in French. There’s no reason, it just is what it is. You have to learn them one by one, but because we grow up with them, one never thinks about it.

How crazy are they? Well, let’s “break down” the “break” family of phrasal verbs: break up, break out, break down, break in, break off, break through, break away, break into, break with, and likely more. And if that’s not confusing enough for the learner of English, consider that “break down” can mean to cease functioning, or it could mean to reduce something to its elements, unless of course you’re talking Bluegrass music.

Consider “come by” – to “come by something honestly” is completely different in concept than “come by tomorrow evening”, and very much different if you’re a Border Collie (to whom it means to circle the sheep in a clockwise direction.)

Even the “F word” lends itself to a handful of quite different meanings, depending on which preposition is used, be it “up”, “off”, or “around”. We’re as adept with our vulgarities as with the rest of our language.

Enough of this ramble! But the next time somebody tries to tell you that English is such an easy language, tell them that is something up with which you will not put.

Similar Posts

  • The Master Race?

    Sometimes I wonder how homo sapiens ever made it to the top of the food chain. In fact, if anyone but ourselves had been in charge of assigning Latin names to the species, would anyone else have called us “wise man”? Given that we are something less than a minute away from Armageddon Midnight on…

  • Scotch

    Whisky is a funny word, but so is Scotch. Let’s have a bit of fun with both. We can’t even get the spelling of whisky straight, and even if we think there are rules, they get broken. Which is kind of appropriate given the subject matter. Whisky, or whiskey, is the anglicisation of uisce beatha,…

  • Tea Leaves

    Last week we looked at constitutional interpretation. Today we look at tea leaf interpretation in general. Not as popular as it used to be, tea leaf reading was a hit at country fairs and amongst those who were into crystal balls, ouija boards, and the like. The idea was to make a cup of tea…

  • A Fragile Deity

    It may be flattering to think that Thor, Odin, or Zeus, or the God of Judaism, Christianity, or Islam (or any of their thousands of sects), can’t get along without me. But I’m afraid I’m not their guy. This isn’t to pick and choose amongst the constellation of deities claiming sole place– that’s your business,…